Opinion

Ruthless Rangers must axe sentimental touch as Ibrox fans pay £60m price of transfer failure

Add as preferred source on Google

As Rangers prepare to enter a new era at Ibrox, there can be no room for sentimentality.

In a domestic season where Rangers once again fell short, the club’s exasperated supporters had only two things to shout about in Scotland all year; an away win at Celtic Park, thank you Barry Ferguson, and Aberdeen’s Scottish Cup victory over Celtic, thank you Sir Alex.

Whilst you won’t hear it being uttered much around Ibrox, this was a season of turning points in the eternal battle with our Old Firm rivals.

The Dons stopped Celtic’s trophy record creeping to 121, keeping Rangers (118) within two pieces of silverware against their rivals, but they could not stop the Ibrox side relinquishing their title as football’s most successful club in 24/25.

This is a devastating blow to a club which has survived the excruciating onslaught of the last decade plus with ‘the most successful club in football’ mantra ringing out around the stadium.

It’s too soon for Celtic to consolidate that title – Rangers hold out hope it may only be temporary – but for those culpable, a sharpened Ibrox axe dangles ruthlessly.

Rangers stadium Ibrox.
Photo by Robbie Jay Barratt – AMA/Getty Images

Rangers pay the price of extreme hesitancy in transfer market

The American buyout signals the start of something new at Ibrox and Rangers are in dire need of freshness.

In fact, hanging on to the old has been less like a delusional relief to the club and more like a shackle around its ankles.

Ianis Hagi became the latest player to leave Rangers under a cloud of transfer controversy, banking the club nothing for his exploits a la Ryan Kent, Alfredo Morelos, Filip Helander and the rest.

PlayerYear joinedTransfer fee paidYear leftTransfer fee received
Alfredo Morelos2017£1m2023End of contract
Carlos Pena2017£2.2m2019Mutual termination
Eduardo Herrera2017£1.5m2020End of contract
Fabio Cardoso2017£1.5m2018Mutual termination
Borna Barisic2018£1.5m2023End of contract
Connor Goldson2018£3.5m2024Undisclosed fee
Eros Grezda2018£2m2019Undisclosed fee
Filip Helander2019£3m2023End of contract
Ryan Kent2019£7m2023End of contract
Ianis Hagi2020£3m2025End of contract
Kemar Roofe2020£4.5m2024End of contract
John Lundstram2021Free2024End of contract
Ridvan Yilmaz2022£5mCURRENTCURRENT
Ben Davies2022£4mCURRENTCURRENT
Rabbi Matondo2022£2.5mCURRENTCURRENT
Todd Cantwell2022£1.5m2024£500k
Sam Lammers2023£3.5m2024Undisclosed fee
Danilo2023£6mCURRENTCURRENT
Jose Cifuentes2023£1mCURRENTCURRENT
Nedim Bajrami2024£3.4mCURRENTCURRENT
Robin Propper2024£1.5mCURRENTCURRENT
TOTALN/A£59.1m £500k
Rangers player trading disasters since 2017

Rangers have been scared to move players on over the last few seasons and paid the ultimate penalty. For a near £60m spend, we’ve recouped only £500k.

The message has been we’ve been lucky to have them – yes the same players who let us down time and again – rather than them being lucky to play for us.

It’s an attitude that has stunk the place out.

One of the single most important aspects of Andrew Cavenagh’s leadership must be a ruthless willingness to move on players, even in their pomp, if it’s the right thing for the club.

We’ve lacked the necessary foresight and self-belief to scale Rangers up to size and only by effective player trading will we close the on and off pitch gap with Celtic.

A failure to heed the lessons of the past now will only see the gap, in terms of trophies and playing power, widen in the next few seasons.

Ruthless Rangers must cut stragglers from underperforming squad

Whoever takes over at Ibrox is inheriting a Rangers squad in something of a mess.

It’s stuffed full of overpaid, underperforming players the bulk of whom have lacked the personality and attitude to wear the jersey. There are still a number of sizeable losses to be cut.

Ben Davies, Jose Cifuentes, Rabbi Matondo, Ridvan Yilmaz, Robin Propper, Kieran Dowell, Nedim Bajrami, Oscar Cortes and Danilo are yet to prove worthy of a place. We’ll be lucky to recoup a fraction of what we paid for them.

Rangers v PSV Eindhoven - UEFA Champions Qualifying Play-Off: First Leg
Photo by Robbie Jay Barratt – AMA/Getty Images

There are others who wanted to cling on. Leon Balogun’s exit is raw and the big defender proved himself in a much better Rangers team. But Tom Lawrence, Neraysho Kasanwirjo and Rafael Fernandes will look back on their Ibrox careers with regret for different reasons.

The problems have run deeper than the players in recent seasons, but what we have is a mish-mash of footballers strung together through Ross Wilson, Michael Beale and Philippe Clement.

Some will remain. Most will go. But there can be no room for the sentimentality which has plagued Rangers pretty much since Dave King and co took charge.